Why is Human Rights Watch labeling these deportations as unlawful?

Human Rights Watch (HRW) asserts that the practice of sending migrants to third-party African nations is a violation of international human rights law. The group argues that these transfers are part of a calculated US policy intended to cause human suffering as a method of deterring future migration. According to HRW, the primary goal is to create a deterrent effect by making the immigration process appear increasingly perilous and unpredictable.

The core of the legal argument rests on the principle of non-refoulement. This international legal standard prohibits states from returning individuals to countries where they face a high risk of torture, cruel treatment, or threats to their life and freedom. HRW reports that in countries such as Cameroon, Equatorial Guinea, and Ghana, deportees have been sent to their countries of origin despite significant risks of persecution, thereby potentially breaching this principle.

The risk of persecution and arbitrary detention

The report highlights specific instances where deportees faced immediate danger upon arrival in third countries. In Eswatini, Ghana, and South Sudan, individuals were reportedly subjected to arbitrary detention and ill-treatment while in custody. The lack of legal protections in these transit or destination countries means that migrants often find themselves in a legal vacuum, stripped of the protections they might have been afforded within the United States.

What are the specific impacts on the deportees?

Deportees have reported severe physical and psychological distress during the removal process. Based on interviews with 24 third-country nationals across six different nations—including the Democratic Republic of Congo, Central African Republic, and Eswatini—the conditions of transport were described as abusive. Some individuals reported being chained for approximately 18 hours during deportation flights, often without being informed of their final destination.

Beyond the physical restraints, the report details a lack of basic human necessities during transit. Migrants have claimed they were denied access to essential medication and were frequently not provided with sufficient food or water. This lack of transparency and care has led to accusations that the US is using human beings as tools of policy to send a message to other potential migrants.

Vulnerability of LGBT individuals and refugees

A particularly critical aspect of the HRW report involves the treatment of vulnerable populations. At least a dozen individuals who identified as lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender (LGBT) were deported to African states where same-sex relations are criminalized. This includes individuals who had been granted refugee status in the US specifically because they faced a high likelihood of persecution in their home countries due to their gender identity or sexual orientation.

How does the US government justify third-country removals?

The US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) maintains that third-country removals are a necessary component of public safety. According to a statement from the DHS, these removals serve as an essential tool to remove the "most dangerous criminal illegal aliens" from American streets. The administration frames the policy as a security measure rather than a deterrent-based humanitarian issue.

The White House has also provided specific context regarding why these third-country transfers occur. White House spokesperson Lauren Bis informed the BBC that these individuals are typically those whose home nations refuse to accept them or those who are subject to court orders preventing their direct return to their countries of origin. To address the issue of voluntary return, the administration stated that any illegal alien wishing to return home can be provided with a free flight and a $3,000 check.

The role of diplomatic assurances

To mitigate legal risks, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) relies on diplomatic assurances. The DHS stated that ICE receives guarantees from destination countries that the individuals being removed will remain safe. However, the agency clarified that once an individual is no longer in the custody of ICE, the agency no longer holds responsibility for their treatment or well-being. This distinction is central to the ongoing debate regarding accountability for human rights abuses during and after the deportation process.

What are the documented outcomes in specific African nations?

The practical outcomes of these deportations vary significantly depending on the destination country. In the Democratic Republic of Congo, HRW noted a high rate of movement following arrival. Of 15 people from Colombia, Peru, and Ecuador deported to the country in April, 11 had returned to their home countries by late September. The group questioned whether these returns were truly voluntary given the uncertain conditions faced in the DRC.

Other countries have shown different patterns of handling deportees:

  • Equatorial Guinea: Received 65 people and quickly processed at least two individuals back to their home countries.
  • Eswatini: Welcomed 32 deportees; while the government claims to respect the dignity of third-country nationals, it noted that three individuals from Yemen, Belize, and Laos recently departed voluntarily.
  • Burundi: Recently announced an agreement to accept migrants deported from the United States.
  • Ghana and Togo: Reports indicate complex transit routes, such as a Nigerian man being moved from Ghana to Togo, raising fears of being "dumped" at borders.

The lack of official commentary from most of the named African nations makes it difficult to ascertain the long-term stability or legal framework governing these deportees within their borders.

Frequently asked questions

What is the principle of non-refoulement?

Non-refoulement is a fundamental principle of international law that prohibits a country from returning asylum seekers or refugees to a country where they would be at risk of persecution, torture, or other serious human rights violations. Violating this principle is considered a breach of international legal standards.

Why are people being sent to countries where they are not citizens?

According to the US administration, these individuals are sent to third countries because their home nations refuse to accept them or because court orders prevent their direct return. However, rights groups argue this is a tactical move to deter migration by creating fear and uncertainty.

How does the US DHS respond to allegations of abuse?

The DHS asserts that ICE obtains diplomatic assurances from destination countries that deportees will be safe. The agency also maintains that its primary responsibility ends once the individual is no longer in ICE custody, shifting the burden of care to the receiving nation.

What are the reported conditions during deportation flights?

Human Rights Watch has documented reports of deportees being chained for up to 18 hours, being denied essential medication, and receiving inadequate food and water. These conditions are described by critics as abusive and part of a policy designed to cause human suffering.

What happens to LGBT refugees in these scenarios?

Some LGBT individuals who were granted protection in the US due to the risk of persecution in their home countries have been deported to African nations where same-sex relations are criminalized. This poses a direct threat to their safety and violates the spirit of their refugee status.

Key takeaways

  • Human Rights Watch claims US deportations to Africa violate international non-refoulement laws.
  • Over 500 people have been sent to non-citizen African countries since 2025.
  • The US government describes these removals as essential tools for public safety.
  • Deportees have reported being chained and denied food or medicine during transit.
  • The policy reportedly targets vulnerable groups, including LGBT refugees.

Conclusion

The use of third-country removals by the United States has become a flashpoint for international human rights debates. While the US administration defends the practice as a necessary security measure and a response to repatriation refusals, organizations like Human Rights Watch view it as a systematic attempt to use human suffering as a deterrent. The documented risks of arbitrary detention, lack of medical care, and the potential violation of the non-refoulement principle suggest a growing tension between US immigration enforcement and international legal obligations. As more nations like Burundi enter agreements to accept deportees, the scrutiny on these opaque diplomatic deals is expected to intensify.