What did the court find about the cult's practices?

Delivering an eight-hour judgment in the port city of Mombasa, Justice Diana Mochache determined that Paul Mackenzie's followers believed he served as "Jesus's mouthpiece." The court heard that Mackenzie instructed members of his cult to starve their children to death under the doctrine that they would "meet Jesus." This religious practice was framed through a specific terminology: burials within the Shakahola forest were referred to as "weddings," where those who died were celebrated as having wedded with Jesus.

The prosecution provided harrowing testimony regarding the enforcement of these doctrines. One co-accused witness stated that Mackenzie told followers that anyone resisting the directive to fast must be forced to go to heaven through "kicks and blows." A witness also recounted the death of a newborn baby; a pregnant woman had been barred from nursing the infant and was instead instructed to fast to death to follow her children. The final verdict confirmed the murder of 191 people, with all but one of the victims being children. While the leaders had pleaded not guilty and insisted no one was forced to die, the court found the evidence of coerced starvation and physical violence compelling.

How did the Shakahola deaths come to light?

The scale of the tragedy was revealed in March 2023, when local herders discovered the first remains. This discovery led to the recovery of more than 400 bodies from shallow graves in the Shakahola forest near the Kenyan coast. The process of exhuming these remains was a grim task undertaken by seventeen men hired from the nearby town, some of whom were paid as little as $8 (£6) a day.

Gravediggers provided chilling details of what they uncovered. James, one of the men tasked with the exhumation, told the BBC that every grave contained at least three bodies, and some remains belonged to children only a few weeks old. He described one massive grave where twelve children's bodies were arranged in a line, stacked one on top of another like clothes. Other workers reported finding children's bodies with their hands and legs tied and their bodies wrapped in bedsheets. Due to the advanced state of decomposition, many of the remains could not be identified. In court documents, several victims are listed only as "unknown male child," identified merely by the location and date of their discovery.

What role did the community play in the investigation?

Although many of Mackenzie's followers traveled from across Kenya to join the cult, the community around Shakahola town had regular, albeit limited, contact with them. Cult members frequently visited the nearby town for supplies and to fetch water from the River Galana. This proximity meant that some of the deceased were familiar to local residents.

The secrecy of the cult's internal life, however, shielded them from suspicion for a long time. Salim Karisa, a gravedigger, noted that while they would sometimes carry people into the forest on motorbikes, the cult's activities were so planned and secretive that no one could discern what was happening inside. The impact on local families has been devastating. Stephen Mwiti, 48, lost all six of his children to the cult, a tragedy compounded by the fact that his former wife was among those convicted of murder alongside Mackenzie. "I'm a happy man, that all persons have been convicted," Mwiti told the BBC, having only been able to find and bury the remains of one son, Samuel.

Why did followers accept the fasting doctrine?

The cult's influence grew through Good News International Ministries, which Mackenzie established in 2003. Over 16 years, the church expanded significantly, drawing thousands of followers through various branches and its own television station, Times TV. Through these channels, Mackenzie broadcast "End Days" sermons that blended religious fervor with conspiracy theories. He preached that education was "evil," modern healthcare was "against the doctrine," and digital identity cards were "the mark of the devil."

The lifestyle within the Shakahola forest was one of isolation and strict adherence to these beliefs. Followers lived in scattered mud houses, practicing a cycle of fasting for several days followed by small meals. For many, like Peter Shukrani, the doctrine was accepted as absolute truth. Shukrani, who joined the church at age eight, described Mackenzie as a "spiritual father." When Shukrani fell ill in the forest, his mother refused to allow him medication, believing that only God could heal him. "My mother would throw away all the medicine I was supposed to take because she believe that only God could heal me," Shukrani said, adding that he likely would have died if he had not been rescued.

What other charges remain against Mackenzie?

While the murder verdict is a significant legal milestone, it is not the end of the legal proceedings for Paul Mackenzie. He and other leaders of the cult face a wide array of other legal cases. These include charges related to terrorism, radicalization, and the criminal denial of education to children.

The current convictions for the deaths of 191 people represent the first time the pastor has faced a verdict on such serious murder charges. Mackenzie was arrested in 2023 following the discovery of the mass graves, and he remains in custody. His sentencing for the murder charges is scheduled for 6 November. The outcome of the remaining cases will determine further accountability for the actions of the Good News International Ministries leadership.

Frequently asked questions

Who was convicted alongside Mackenzie?

Twenty-eight other leaders of the cult were also convicted of murder. All defendants had pleaded not guilty, maintaining that no one was forced to die or fast against their will.

How many bodies were recovered from Shakahola forest?

More than 400 bodies were discovered in shallow graves. The specific murder convictions handed down in this case relate to 191 of those deaths, the vast majority of whom were children.

When will sentencing take place?

The court has scheduled the sentencing for 6 November. Mackenzie remains in custody pending this date.

Did any followers defend Mackenzie?

Yes. Some followers, such as Peter Shukrani, maintained a positive view of Mackenzie despite the tragedy. Shukrani described him as a "good person who cares" and expressed that he still viewed him as a spiritual figure.

Are further trials expected?

Yes. Mackenzie and other leaders still face separate legal proceedings involving charges of terrorism, radicalization, and denying children their right to education.

Key takeaways

  • Paul Mackenzie was convicted of murdering 191 people, almost all of whom were children.
  • The court found that the cult used coercion, including physical violence, to enforce fasting.
  • Over 400 bodies were recovered from shallow graves in Shakahola forest starting in March 2023.
  • Twenty-eight other cult leaders were also found guilty of murder.
  • Sentencing is set for 6 November, with additional charges of terrorism and radicalization still pending.
  • Many victims remain unidentified due to the advanced state of decomposition.

Conclusion

The Mombasa High Court's decision marks a definitive moment in the Shakahola forest tragedy, establishing criminal responsibility for the starvation deaths that claimed hundreds of lives. By convicting Paul Mackenzie and 28 of his leaders, the justice system has addressed the immediate horror of the 191 murders. However, the scale of the discovery—over 400 bodies—and the ongoing legal battles regarding terrorism and the denial of education suggest that the full impact of the cult's influence is still being reckoned with. As the community processes the loss of children and the breakdown of social trust, the legal and social consequences of the Good News International Ministries continue to unfold.