How did investigators obtain warrants for cell-site simulators?
Judges in Minnesota and Pennsylvania signed warrants on January 30 and 31, 2026, authorizing the use of cell-site simulators against the phone of Jerome Richardson. These applications were issued just twelve days after a protest at Cities Church in St. Paul, Minnesota, where Richardson, then a 21-year-old college student, helped produce coverage for journalist Don Lemon. The stated purpose of the warrants, according to motions filed by Richardson's lawyers, was "locating and arresting him." Richardson is among 39 people charged with conspiring to violate worshippers’ civil rights and interfering with religious worship during the January 18 service.
Beyond targeting Richardson, the investigative scope extended to other individuals present at the demonstration. Court documents show that agents applied for cell-site simulator warrants targeting the phones of journalist Georgia Fort and Jamael Lundy, a then-Minnesota State Senate candidate. Additionally, investigators sought pen register orders—tools capable of logging the numbers a phone contacts—for Fort and a number traced by WIRED to Don Lemon. However, the current record is incomplete regarding the outcome of these specific requests. It remains unclear whether a judge approved the applications for Fort and Lundy, or whether investigators actually deployed a cell-site simulator to locate Richardson.
Why target Richardson with this surveillance tool?
The decision to use cell-site simulators—often called Stingrays or IMSI catchers—to find Richardson has come under scrutiny due to the circumstances of his arrest. Richardson, then a senior at Temple University, did not flee. Instead, he voluntarily surrendered to a federal courthouse in Philadelphia on February 2, 2026, just two days after a warrant was signed. On January 31, the day before his surrender, Richardson had even posted a YouTube video stating he expected to enter federal custody "in the coming days," suggesting he had no intention of evading authorities.
Following his surrender, Richardson was released on bond that same afternoon. A former federal prosecutor, speaking on condition of anonymity, noted that while using a simulator to locate a target is not necessarily unusual in counterterrorism cases, the tactics in this instance appeared aggressive. Given Richardson's public anticipation of his arrest, the necessity of such an intrusive tool is a central question for the defense. Furthermore, the affidavits used to justify the tracking claimed video evidence showed Richardson, Lemon, and Fort "chanting with agitators," a claim prosecutors have since conceded was inaccurate regarding Lemon and Fort.
Accuracy issues in the warrant applications
The reliability of the information provided to judges is a major point of contention in the ongoing legal proceedings. Defense filings highlight that the false claim regarding the journalists' participation in chanting was not an isolated error; according to Fort’s lawyers, the government acknowledged that this inaccurate description appeared in at least 15 separate warrant affidavits. This discrepancy raises significant questions about the accuracy of the information presented to investigators seeking judicial authorization for surveillance.
The use of these devices is also governed by internal Department of Homeland Security (DHS) policy, which dictates that cell-site simulators should only be deployed in the "fraction of cases in which the capability is best suited to achieve specific public safety objectives." In the case of the Cities Church investigation, the specific public safety justification for employing such high-level surveillance to find a student who was publicly preparing for his arrest remains unexplained in the available records.
What other surveillance methods were used in the investigation?
The pursuit of those connected to the Cities Church protest involved a wide array of contentious investigative tactics. According to court records, the DHS utilized customs authority to demand telephone and YouTube records from journalists—a process that requires no prior judicial approval. Defense attorneys have identified 92 such customs summonses and are currently challenging the government’s authority to issue them.
The breadth of the investigation even extended to consumer data. Agents sought records to identify every individual who had purchased a specific type of beanie at REI stores in the Minneapolis–St. Paul area over a period exceeding two years. This level of granular tracking, combined with the pursuit of digital records and the use of simulators, paints a picture of an expansive and highly aggressive investigative campaign. The government's initial attempts to secure arrest warrants also faced judicial pushback; a magistrate judge refused five of eight warrants, and after an appeals court rejected the Justice Department's attempt to override that decision, the department withdrew its request. In that filing, a chief judge noted that two of the rejected subjects were a journalist and his producer who showed no evidence of criminal behavior.
What privacy concerns do cell-site simulators raise?
Cell-site simulators function by impersonating legitimate cell phone towers to intercept signals from nearby devices. While they are effective at locating a specific target, they are inherently indiscriminate. In the process of capturing a target's data, they also collect identifying information from every other cellular device in the vicinity, including those belonging to innocent bystanders. This capability has led privacy advocates to label them "dragnet surveillance tools."
The secrecy surrounding these devices is also a significant concern. FBI records released in 2023 revealed that law enforcement agencies borrowing simulators from the FBI were required to keep the details of their use secret, even when presenting information in court. Cooper Quintin, a senior staff technologist at the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), has characterized the use of such technology against members of the press as an "appalling attack on the First Amendment." The EFF has spent years researching these devices and developing detection software; using such tools, WIRED found evidence suggesting a simulator may have been deployed near the 2024 Democratic National Convention in Chicago, though the purpose and operator of that deployment remain unknown.
Frequently asked questions
Did judges approve simulator use against Georgia Fort?
It is currently unknown. Court records reviewed by WIRED do not establish whether judges signed the applications targeting Fort or Minnesota State Senate candidate Jamael Lundy. Fort’s legal team stated in July that prosecutors were unsure if the surveillance applications had been authorized or had yielded any evidence.
Was a cell-site simulator actually deployed?
The available filings do not confirm whether a simulator was actually used. While Richardson’s lawyers have filed a motion to suppress evidence obtained through phone tracking, the motion does not specify if that evidence came from a cell-site simulator or another method.
Why were journalists included in the investigation?
Prosecutors charged Don Lemon and Georgia Fort with conspiring to violate civil rights following their coverage of the Cities Church protest. However, a chief judge in an appeals court filing noted that two of the subjects for whom warrants were initially sought were a journalist and his producer, and that there was no evidence they engaged in criminal behavior.
What charges did Jerome Richardson face?
Richardson was charged with conspiring to violate worshippers’ civil rights and interfering with religious worship at Cities Church. He has defended his actions, stating he was providing logistics support for Lemon's coverage and that his involvement was a "price of being unapologetic about humanity and love of Christ."
Can law enforcement keep simulator use secret?
Yes. FBI records from 2023 show that police agencies borrowing simulators must agree to keep the details of their use secret, a practice that has drawn heavy criticism from civil liberties groups regarding judicial oversight.
Key takeaways
Federal investigators sought cell-site simulator warrants to locate Jerome Richardson, a producer for Don Lemon, following a protest at Cities Church. These applications, along with requests for pen register orders on journalists, occurred despite evidence suggesting the targets were not fleeing. Furthermore, prosecutors admitted that inaccurate claims about the journalists' behavior appeared in at least 15 warrant affidavits. The investigation also utilized 92 customs summonses to obtain digital and consumer records without prior judicial approval, highlighting a broad and controversial use of investigative powers.
Conclusion
The warrants and summonses involved in the Cities Church investigation illustrate a significant expansion of surveillance tactics used against individuals connected to a single protest. From the use of cell-site simulators to the aggressive application of customs authority, the government's methods have raised fundamental questions regarding the First Amendment and the necessity of such intrusive tools. As defense motions regarding evidence suppression and the legality of these surveillance methods move through the courts, the case remains a critical touchstone for the limits of federal investigative power in the digital age.
